Sunday, November 9, 2025

"Simple Answers" Sermon from 11/9/25

 

Sermon from First UMC East Greenbush, Luke 20:27-38

          It’s an absurd situation … intentionally. Even for back then when life expectancy was shorter and there were no resources for family planning, even then, it’s an absurd situation. Seven brothers, each one dying one at a time, without children and then marrying the same woman until finally all seven have died and the widow remains. It is intentionally absurd because there is no genuine curiosity behind it. We are told in the first line of this passage from Luke that those asking it, the Sadducees, “say there is no resurrection.” So we already know they do not believe what Jesus is teaching. So they come up to Jesus with this scenario to see what he will say. They aren’t looking for enlightenment, they are looking to prove him wrong, to make him look foolish, they are looking for a “gotcha” moment.

         A gotcha moment is when someone seems to be asking a question but is really just hoping to trick you, puzzle you, or make you look stupid. People love these moments. They love to see people stammer, stutter or admit that they don’t know something. I can imagine that if this scene was taking place today, there would be a big group of people standing around with their cell phones up, hitting record and hoping to get a big moment to post on Instagram. It’s like all those cameras positioned around the plane, watching as a president descends down the staircase, hoping to catch a trip, a stumble, anything that people will click on or laugh at or use to prove a point about weakness. That’s where Jesus is standing in this scene from Luke, he is at the top of the stairs, about to walk down and the Sadducees are sure hoping he will miss a step.

           But he doesn’t. Like so many other times in the Gospels, Jesus avoids the trap and not because he sidesteps it, but rather because he faces it with the truth, a deeper truth. Jesus answers this question by taking it to another level. He will not engage with their premise because he knows they lack understanding. It’s like the Sadducees are looking at a map of their neighborhood and thinking it’s a map of the earth. They aren’t seeing beyond what is in front of them. They are caught in the details, the legalities, the day to day existence they see and trying to apply that to eternity, to the ways of God, to the great Divine mystery.

           I believe that questions of faith are important. I know that in my own faith journey, questions of faith have deepened my relationship with God and strengthened my faith. There are many examples in the Bible of people wrestling with God, crying out their doubts, digging deeper, and coming out changed … renewed, lit from within by a burning desire to stay close to God. But there is a difference between asking questions to dive deeper into a relationship with God and asking questions to put up walls and barriers on that relationship.

           Before I moved to New York about a year and a half ago, I was a youth pastor at a large church. I got to walk alongside young people as they challenged, questioned, wondered at and celebrated their faith. I loved sitting with teens and young adults as they started asking questions about what they believe. The questions showed that they were taking their faith seriously, they were figuring out how to apply it their lives, their goals and their decisions. They were making sense of the world and inviting the Holy Spirit into that. And, at a certain point, they had to decide whether to dive in to the mystery and accept that we can’t understand everything, we can’t always make sense of God’s ways- and embrace faith or decide to pull away. And honestly, that’s a decision we probably make over and over in our lives as we grow, mature and encounter new struggles and new questions.  When we have asked all our questions, will we embrace faith and accept Divine mystery, or will we keep trying to figure it all out for ourselves?

           When Jesus answers the Sadducees, he tries to explain to them how God’s ways are different than what we see in the here and now. He talks about things that defy laws and defy maps and defy what we can experience in the here and now. He talks about being “like angels” and the dead being raised and being “children of the resurrection.” For those of us living here and now, it’s difficult to understand these things. Difficult to wrap our minds around God’s love that never ends, even when we die. Difficult to imagine a time when all of this will be no more and we will be made new in a resurrection with Christ. Death is such a harsh reality and we spend a lot of time trying to wrap our minds around it, run from it, avoid it, worry about it and plan around it. It’s hard to imagine a time when death will be no more.

           Since we moved here, my favorite place to walk my dog is a cemetery. I live near Albany Rural Cemetery and my dog and I have had the opportunity to explore its many paths, look at its many colorful trees and listen to the many sounds of the creeks and waterfalls. It’s a place where I go when I want to clear my head and just be present in the moment. I don’t listen to music or talk on the phone, I just hear the sounds of the birds, the rustling leaves and my footsteps. I look at the distant hills, the flowers and blue sky. And I also look at the graves. I think about the stories behind them. I look at the grave with the life-sized statue of a curious three-year old boy looking at a book and think about the mother who had that made, the mother who still wanted to see her son standing there, innocent and present. I look at the big fancy towers and marble buildings and think about the family patriarchs and matriarchs who decided on materials that would last, stones big enough to be around for a long time, structures sturdy enough for whatever weather may come. I look at the freshly placed flags by the graves of veterans and think of the people who placed them there, people who are devoted to doing the research, finding the graves and carefully placing the flags so that the legacy of courage, sacrifice and dedication isn’t forgotten. I look at the graves with matching benches next to them, benches made by loved ones who couldn’t bear the thought of leaving them there and wanted to make a spot where they could still be together.

          All of it out of love. In the hospital I sit with families as they try to soak up every last second, every last breath before the machine stops beeping. Death is a harsh reality. And it is hard to let go.

          So I get it. If a man marries a woman and she doesn’t have children and he dies and then she marries the brother and he dies and the next brother and the next and the next … who will she be married to in “the resurrection?” It’s almost a way of asking, how do we keep this life going? How do we hold on to the attachments we have here? How to we make sense of things and feel safe? How can we make what is unknown feel predictable?

          Like the beautiful stones placed with love, we want a way to still experience the ones we love here on earth.

          But Jesus says, it’s not like that. And maybe that sounds scary, maybe that sounds like something we don’t understand or can’t predict or control or buy or purchase insurance for, but Jesus says …. It’s so much better than that. Jesus says that the dead are “children of God” and that even though they are dead . . . to God “all of them are alive.”

          We are God’s children. God’s love continues across all space and time, it is more than the here and now. God isn’t letting us go. God has got us, even if that isn’t the “gotcha” moment the Sadducees are expecting.

          So breathe easy, it’s ok if we don’t understand it all. We are God’s children and that will never end. God’s love is so much more than our attempts to make sense of things.

           When I am working as a hospital chaplain, I often do rounds in the post-partum unit. I give new parents some time and space to process whatever thoughts, feelings and emotions they are having and then I ask if they would like me to pray. And each family has different things they would like me to pray for, like health or happiness- and I do, but every single time I look down at those tiny little brand new lives, those little toes and soft shoulders, my heart feels overwhelmed by how beloved they are. So innocent and so new, so clearly God’s children. And I pray that every day of their lives they will know how much they are loved. As their skin wrinkles, their bones stretch, their minds deepen and their joints crack, even then, that they will know every moment of every day that they are God’s beloved children. And that is my prayer for you. The Sadducees brought Jesus a complicated question, and he gave them a much deeper, much bigger answer, but also a much simpler answer … it’s love … God’s love in this life and the next.

No comments:

Post a Comment